Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Neill,
You are definitely getting there. German breads by definition are heavier and more dense than other forumulas; it's a sort of national marque. This has to do not only with the weight of the whole grains used (rye, eg), but also the fact that rye and whole wheat do not have the gluten percentage of bread flour.
The ideal temperature for retardation is 40 degrees Fahrenheit. That's fairly normal for North American fridges. At that temp, you can leave the dough for as long as 18 hours. At 50 degrees, it shouldn't retard for more than about 8 hours. These figures are for wild yeast/sourdough breads, but with proper commercial yeast amounts, they would still apply for other formulas.
Personally, I would empty the oven of all coals and ash before baking, then bake directly on the brick with the oven door in place. (Except for pan breads, of course.) This, along with proper steam, will produce maximum spring/volume. The steam should be vented about halfway through the bake to allow the crust to develop.
Your photographs of the bulk dough do suggest they are verging on over-fermented, so a drop in temp would help. If you're converting a commercial yeast/one-day bread to the retardation technique, try cutting the commercial yeast back by about half.
Jim
Proofing - raising questions????
Collapse
X
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Good job! You got nice volume on them, colors are good. From here you will continue to fine tune all the factors involved. Juggling the balls of oven temperature, final proof and all will get easier as you go. I think you are well on the way.
My best to you!
DutchLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
It really does pay to ask questions here!!!
Proof positive. I took your advice and made up the dough on saturday night ata round 9-10 pm and left it to proof on the dining room table (a room rarely used and not heated), The picture shows the rewsults of the 2 spicy bun mix in the blue containers, a multigrain and German multigrain behing them and a double Russell Jeavons white bread recipe in the bowl behind those. I checked the temp on arising sunday am (well around 8.00 am and it was 15?C.Next time, I will proof them in the fridge as I feel that they over proofed, but they shaped up and cooked fine. The German multigrain was still a little dense and rather heavy but that could be the very nature of the beast.
I was a little impatient with the first bake (visitors about to leave), and put them in at 750?F for 10 minutes. The buns got a little burnt on their bases but tasted great hot, straight out of the oven with butter dripping from them liberally. Hot rolls for lunch.... what could be better!
I let the oven cool down, but left the coals in there and cooked the second batch with the help of a few water sprays to increase the humidity.
I used tins and trays (wife's insistance) but did one piece directly on the floor.
Have a few ideas to try next bake.
Neill4 PhotosLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Drake, James,
Retarding doughs made with commercial yeast can be tricky, because you usually have to reduce the amount of yeast by somewhere around a half. Otherwise, it will overferment.
I'd suggest trying Hamelman's 5-grain bread. It's made with commercial yeast, but the formula is designed to allow for retardation at the bulk stage. You do have to deflate the dough several times as it cools, though.
JimLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
All of the recipes I am currently using that have an overnight proof/retardation in the fridge don't have any commercial yeast at all...
The preferment ones, that start with a commercial yeast, have you making the preferment the previous day, but then making the dough, bulk rising, shaping and proofing on day two...
I guess I would be worried about the commercial yeast over fermenting in the fridge overnight...Leave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Thanks Jim,
Very helpful. Drew, I haven't been doing a pre-ferment -- but I will start. That's a good idea. The last time I made the same formula a number of days in a row, I was trying to eliminate variables, which really helped.
I think I am ready to add the preferment.
That would mean one day or preferment, mixing and a bulk rise, boule shaping and an overnight proof. Should be good.
Does that sound like a good schedule?
JamesLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
James,
The question of whether to let retarded loaves warm up was posted a fair bit previously. However, I think you'll find that straight from the fridge to the hearth works best. That way, when the hearth is ready, the bread is ready. A lot fewer timing issues to deal with. Also, it's much easier to dock cold dough than warm. Jeffrey Hamelman points out that the difference between a 40 degree F loaf and a 60 degree loaf hitting a 500 degree hearth is minimal in the scheme of things. It MIGHT add a minute to the bake time, but no more than that. I'm really finding that cold doughs result in better caramelization of the grain sugars on the crust.
Having said that, there are many opinions out there about this question. Nancy Silverton recommends letting the loaves come up to 58 F before baking. I've tried it, but juggling both the oven and the loaf temps is crazy making. Not only that, but you risk overfermented loaves if your timing isn't perfect.
JimLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
You need a bigger mixer! I am loving the SP-5!
I go for moderate gluten development and then fold during fermentation, that seems to be working our really well, and I still get my hands in the dough.
Also are you using a preferment at all?
DrakeLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Hey Drew and Dutch,
Thanks for the input -- that's what I did. I think I am a stuck record. I ended up with too much yeast, and my boule slightly deflated right before it reached the oven. This is what I was doing a few months ago. Plus, I have the good American bread flour, which is giving me more structure, so you wouldn't think this would be a problem. I wonder if I will ever learn. Oh well.
The bread was good, but I am going to cut back on the yeast, and start weighing ingredients (as soon as my scale arrives). Hand kneading and measuring by feel is still fun, though the King Arthur flour is very resilient compared with the Italian Tipo 00. I need more muscles.
Next time I will cut back on the yeast, and take a photo.
Thanks guys.
JamesLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
I have been going straight from the fridge to the oven with great results!
DrakeLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Why yes you can! YOu and I hadn't chatted through the forum in some time! IMHO I would say you dould do either. Colder dough might add a minute or two to the cooking time. I can't think of how warming would otherwise improve the quality of the loaf. If it were me I would definitely go straight from the fridge to the oven.
Best
DutchLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Can I add on to this thread?
I have a boule sitting in the refrigerator. It's in a real linen lined banneton, just waiting to go. King Arthur general purpose flour (more on that later), hand kneaded yesterday.
My question is whether you pop it straight in the oven, or leave it out in the banneton at room temperature (mid 60s here) for a while for baking?
Thanks for the input.
JamesLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Uno,
Good thoughts, though I don't think a light misting of spray oil in whatever container used will affect the rise, and it also prevents wetter doughs from sticking to the sides.
Most of the information I have, particularly for wild yeast doughs, is that both bulk and secondary rises should take place at about 76 F in a draft free environment (unless retardation is used for the secondary, of course). Drafts are not a problem if the risings are done in covered containers. As you say, cooler and longer is better than hotter and shorter, or, worse case, hotter and longer.
I think you nailed it when you said the doughs were probably over-risen.
It's worth pointing out, though, that in a wintertime kitchen (as in OZ right now), the humidity level can be a factor depending on the home heating type. Neill, you might want to get a cheap analog humidity gauge; the level should be in the 50 to 60 per cent range. In my case, it's natural gas, so the kitchen can be very dry without a humidifier on the furnace or a pot of water simmering on the stove.
JimLeave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Jims on it.. but I will add this..
In the heat you describe it sound like the dough was over proofed. Remember the dough shouldn't "look" like the loaf in size before you bake it, properly proofed dough is smaller than the end product. Instead of finding a warm location find a location that is going to remain consistent in temperature during your proof times, this way even if it is a cooler area being that its at a consistent temp you can weed out other factors effecting the end product, such as yeast, dough temp, mix time, etc. Besides I believe a longer cooler rise is the best for flavor.
I really don't like the oiled bowel thing I don't think its necessary and may actually hinder the dough rise. I used large plastic cans (kinda like garbage cans only food grade) and most of my doughs are pretty wet. When punching down some may stick to the sides of your bowl but this easily comes off.
Second kneading, like Jim said loose it, by kneading again your collapsing all the progress the dough just made and in those temp it probably just didn't have the strength to rise again. After the yeast has consumed its food source past a certain point there is no return and the dough begins to break itself down. I'm not real familiar with wholegrain doughs but I'm pretty sure a second kneading is not a common thing.
I really think your problem here was the proofing times and temp. more than anything. Scout out that location that remains at an even temp.Leave a comment:
-
Re: Proofing - raising questions????
Thanks guys,
I was thinking maybe of manufacturing a specialy 'proofing cabinet' to improve the final result.
I am still experimenting - well trying out the ingredients with different yeasts, flours and formulas.
I'm finding that this - what we take for granted - simple task of breadmaking, is in fact a science where you need to get everything right to get the best results.
We have another big family get together with a special family announcement next week-end, so will put your thoughts to the test.
Again, thanks for your valued advice.
NeillLast edited by nissanneill; 08-05-2007, 03:22 PM.Leave a comment:





Leave a comment: