Forum Notice: The forum has been upgraded and restored to November 2. Posts and new accounts created after November 2 were lost. Sorry for the inconvenience.
If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
we will add a vent if we decide to go with that idea.
having built several steam locomotives to run around our backyard track we are familiar
with the power of steam, but i do appreciate your input
Any material with water added to it will be problematic if you have a steel inner and outer dome. I'd be worrying about creating a bomb. That steam will be sealed between the steel, remember that water expands 1000 times.
I will be building an oven using a steel dome inside another steel dome, and it got me to ask why you need to use refractory cement if you have the steel against the fire.
why not use concrete or stucco for the thermal mass?.
Hey metalmaster...what size metal domes are you planning on using? I had initially considered using a dome inside a dome but ran into the problem of finding a dome large enough to go over my 40" dome...I talked to a manufacturer and they quoted me around $1500 for a 48" dome, if they had it in inventory, because they wouldn't be doing a run for one piece. So, I moved on to creating a refractory layer over my dome and then insulating that, followed by a stucco outer finish.
To answer your question...as Dmun said, concrete will break down under high heat.
I'm interested in how you are planning to put it all together...are you going to weld the domes to steel plate? What kind of insulated base are you planning on making?
I read somewhere (gonna look it up again) that low iron clay was used in fire brick because the high iron content would rust and the smell could permeate the food being cooked. Would a steel dome have the same problem?
Because the concrete will break down at oven heat.
If you are using two steel domes, why not just pound in foundry sand between the two layers? That will get as hard as it needs to be, and won't crack up in road vibration conditions.
I will be building an oven using a steel dome inside another steel dome, and it got me to ask why you need to use refractory cement if you have the steel against the fire.
why not use concrete or stucco for the thermal mass?.
Yes steel has a greater thermal flux density, hence the question about whether the thick walls were a compensation or not. The majority of brick ovens have 4" walls. But a lot of ovens, specifically mobile ones that use cast refractory or ceramic prefab have 2.5" walls & are generally regarded to work just fine. So it's a valid option to consider using 2.5" walls. If it suits the OP goals, it would save him a lot of time, money & weight.
.
Yeah, I may have to reconsider the 4" thickness. If 2.5" will get the job done, and for all the reasons you mentioned... time, weight, money, that may be the new plan. I could also double up with the ceramic insulation and still have the thermal properties.
The volume of 48" sphere is 57906 cu. in.
minus
the volume of 40" sphere, 33510 cu. in.
equals 24396 divided by two (hemisphere) equals 12198 cu. in.
divided by 1728 equals 7 cubic feet more or less.
I get fifteen sixty pound bags of concrete from this website:
Refmix comes in 22 pound bags so you would need 41 of them.
There may be cheaper castable refractories than refmix, which is, after all, a mortar not a castable. Still. Yikes.
Thanks for the calculations...so 50 bags is not that far off after all. I'm going to need to rethink this aspect and come up with a cheaper alternative...I know there are homemade recipes for refractory using fireclay, I'll have to do some research on that.
Yes steel has a greater thermal flux density, hence the question about whether the thick walls were a compensation or not. The majority of brick ovens have 4" walls. But a lot of ovens, specifically mobile ones that use cast refractory or ceramic prefab have 2.5" walls & are generally regarded to work just fine. So it's a valid option to consider using 2.5" walls. If it suits the OP goals, it would save him a lot of time, money & weight.
The steel doesn't retain heat, it transmits it. You need thermal mass, and if it were me, i'd use a thin layer of refractory blanket over the steel so it doesn't expand and break your masonry layer (metal has a much higher co-efficient of expansion than masonry) There's a quarter inch refractory blanket that the masonry heater guys use between the core and the outer layer because of the same problem.
Pretty much every brick built oven (except mine) has a four inch wall thickness. You may not need it for thermal mass, but a thinner layer would be much more likely to break apart in a vibrational situation like a mobile oven. Modular ovens are 2.5 inches thick, it's true, but I think fired ceramic units are MUCH more strong than anything you are going to cast out of concrete.
Is the desire for 4" refractory a compensation for thermal properties of the steel? I'm asking because a lot of ovens, particularly those intended for pizza or live fire cooking have walls a lot closer to 2.5", which would save a lot of cost & weight. Usually only retained heat (bread) ovens would have walls of 4" or more.
The volume of 48" sphere is 57906 cu. in.
minus
the volume of 40" sphere, 33510 cu. in.
equals 24396 divided by two (hemisphere) equals 12198 cu. in.
divided by 1728 equals 7 cubic feet more or less.
I get fifteen sixty pound bags of concrete from this website:
Leave a comment: